Chipuning Tools Reviews
CHIPTUNING TOOLS REVIEWS: CMD VS ALIENTECH
Chiptuning tools are the most important tools of a tuning company. When you are new in the world of chiptuning / remapping it is not easy to make the right choice regarding the chiptuningtool that you need to buy. There are many different chiptuning tool suppliers. Which brands and chiptuning tools are the best? We help you to make things clear. Today we compare CMD versus Alientech.
Introduction of chiptuning tools suppliers
CMD Flash (Flashtec SA) and Alientech SRL are two of the largest and most professional chiptuning tools suppliers on the market today. Both companies have been around for many years and are originally from North Italy located within 150 kilometers from each other. Another competitor named Dimsport is also located in the north of Italy. It seems the Italians dominate the tuning scene. Which company is the best?
History of Chiptuning Tools Suppliers
History of CMD Flash
This company is now called Flashtec SA. The company has Italian roots and is now based in Switzerland. They have been in business for many years and CMD was one of the first to introduce a stable OBD protocol for the Bosch EDC16. CMD has products like CMDFLASH OBD, CMDFlash – BDM, CMDFlash – Nexus, Boost ST10/C167, BOOT-MODE BOSCH MEDC17 TRICORE, MAP3D, My Personal Flasher and SpiderBOOT.
History of Alientech SRL
Since 1991 they have been working in the field of engine tuning and chiptuning (ECU tuning). During the years they released many products like ECM2001, KESS, Powergate, BDM pro, ECM Titanium, KESSv2, K-TAG and Powergate 3. Alientech is one of the first companies to develop stable protocols with recovery functions for other ECUs than those developed by Bosch or Siemens. They developed protocols for JTAG Nexus, JTAG Renesas, Mitsubishi bootloader, etc.
Users of CMD Flashtec and Alientech
Both companies have many customers and are very appreciated. This makes these companies stable which is important for a long term partnership. The customers pay an annual fee and this is also a commitment to their costumers. They can be sure the companies will develop new protocols.
ECU tuning, development of new read write protocols
In the world of tuning / chiptuning / remapping it’s all about the ECU. For example, as soon as VAG brings out a new car/engine, the ECU is immediately taken out and many tests are done to try and successfully read/write/modify the software in the ECU and to create a stable read/write protocol for their customers. Of course every company has its own knowledge and network to do research and development. In reality we see that both Alientech and CMD can do many the same ECUs. The time of release of new protocols differs from 1 month to 4 years after introduction of a new engine of a car brand. But if one chiptuning tools supplier has a protocol ready, in most cases within a few weeks/months the other supplier has this protocol ready too.
In our own experience we know that customer support is very important. We use the chiptuning tools from CMD and Alientech for 85% of our tuning. We have tuned over 10.000 ECUs with their tools and tested every protocol. The protocols are not in all cases perfect and a lot of mistakes can be made by the customer who uses the tools. Both companies have reliable support if you are a professional tuner with enough experience. If you are a newby, this is different. In this case we advise you to ask for advice from your tuning files supplier. A good tuning file supplier does not only sells files, but also writes the tuning files themselves in the cars of their own customers for their own companies. They use the tools daily on all kinds of cars and ECU’s and can tell you how to avoid traps and give you all the tips and tricks to make the reading and writing successful in real time.
Chiptuning by OBD or BOOT?
Both Alientech and CMD have many read/write tools. We can divide them in 2 groups
1. OBD read/write by diagnostic port (KESS v2, CMDFlash OBD)
- Easy to use
- Takes less time to work on
- Not many accessories needed
- Not all ECU’s are available. (most new ECU’s are only done directly on ECU.)
- If reading/writing is not successful for some reas0n, recovery is not always possible
- Only partial data is read
2. Directly on ECU read/write (KTAG, CMDFlash BDM – Boot)
- The highest amount of protocols available. Old ECU’s, new ECU’s, future ECU’s, special brands
- Newer ECU’s protcols finished earlier after introduction of ECU
- Protocols are more stable, better recovery if needed
- Most chips can be read. eprom, mpc, eeprom. (important in case of immo off, recovery, etc.)
- More difficult to use. you have to take out ECU of the car, open the case and use the manual to connect the ECU to the tool.
- Not foolproof, user can make mistakes that can destroy the ECU
- Connecting takes more time. Especially when testing on dyno this can be a problem.
CMDFlash Slave OBD Flasher (only OBD) € 1,746.00
CMDFlash Slave OBD + BOOT ( st10, tricore) (OBD + directly on ECU) € 3.449.00
CMDFlash Slave OBD + BOOT ( st10, tricore ) + BDM 5xx (OBD + directly on ECU) €4,280.00
K-TAG Slave Full (All protocols enabled) price (no OBD, only directly on ECU) € 1,200.00
KESSv2 Slave OBD Flasher (Car + Bike + Agriculture protocols) price (only OBD) € 3,400.00
KESSv2 Slave OBD Flasher (Car + Bike + Truck protocols) price (only OBD) € 3,400.00
KESSv2 Slave OBD Flasher (Car + Bike protocols) price (only OBD) €2,000.00
KESSv2 Slave OBD Flasher (Truck + Agriculture protocols) price (only OBD) € 3,400.00
KESSv2 Slave OBD Flasher Full (all protocols enabled) price (only OBD) € 3.495.00
New chip tuning protocols, Updates, revisions, bugfixes
Both companies use an annual subscription. At first glance this seems like a waste of money but in reality this is very useful and important. This makes it possible for the companies to develop new protocols for new ECU’s. You will always be up to date with the newest protocols, newest checksum corrections and bugfixes. This is the main reason why clone chip tuning tools are not interesting. The market is constantly evolving. Updates of protocols are crucial.
Comparison table tuning tool supplier
+++ = positive experience
— = negative experience
|company name||Alientech SRL||CMD FLASHTEC SA||Other supplier|
|price||+++ especially in case of KTAG||+++||++|
|development new protocols||++||+++ rightnow EDC17C64, Simos 8.5, SIM12 possible||–|
The best chiptuning tools – conclusion
What chiptuning tools are the best? This depends on the user. Both brands have very good products for a reasonable price. Do you want to keep things easy and simple? Buy an OBD tool like Kess v2 or CMDFlash OBD. Do you want to modify many different brands from all over the world and especially newer ECUs? Then buy a boot tool like CMDFlash + boot + KTAG of Alientech. Do you want full readouts? A large number of ECU’s possible to modify for the lowest price? Buy a KTAG made byAlientech. Is your business is growing fast and you have enough money to invest? Buy OBD and boottools from both brands. In this case you can modify many types of ECU’s and in case of a failure, you can use the other tool for a second try.
Have you made your choice already? Buy a chiptuning tool at ZIPtuning! We offer very low prices to our customers, the lowest prices on the market today!
Do you have questions about specific products made by CMD or Alientech or perhaps other brands? We have daily experience with most of the tools suppliers. Contact us.